INSIGHTS

Articles & Insights.

Thought leadership on the legal, regulatory, and business issues shaping the healthcare industry.

REAL ISSUES.

PRACTICAL INSIGHTS.

AHEAD OF THE CURVE.

Management Fees in MSO Structures: Fixed Fees, Percentage Fees, Fair Market Value and Fee-Splitting Risk

One of the most important provisions in any Management Services Agreement (“MSA”) is also one of the most frequently misunderstood: How does the MSO get paid?

Healthcare businesses use a variety of management-fee structures, including fixed monthly fees, cost-plus arrangements, percentage-of-revenue fees, and combinations of these approaches. There is no single fee structure that works for every MSO.

The appropriate structure depends on what the MSO actually provides, where the business operates, who the parties are, and how money moves through the organization.

Why Management Fees Require Special Attention

In an ordinary business relationship, two companies generally have substantial flexibility to negotiate compensation.

Healthcare is different.

Depending on the arrangement, management compensation may implicate state fee-splitting prohibitions, corporate practice of medicine restrictions, patient-brokering laws, and federal or state fraud-and-abuse laws.

This is particularly important when the MSO or its owners are not licensed healthcare professionals.

The analysis becomes even more significant when the management company has relationships with referral sources or when federal healthcare program business is involved.

Fixed Management Fees

A fixed management fee can provide a relatively straightforward structure.

For example, the professional practice may pay the MSO an established monthly amount in exchange for specified administrative and management services.

But calling a payment “fixed” does not automatically make the arrangement appropriate. The amount still needs to make sense in relation to the services, resources, personnel, facilities, technology, and other infrastructure actually being provided.

Percentage-Based Management Fees

Percentage-based fees are attractive because they allow management compensation to increase as the practice grows.

They also require careful analysis.

Some jurisdictions restrict or prohibit certain forms of fee splitting between licensed healthcare professionals and non-professionals. The applicable rules may depend on the state, type of professional practice, services performed, and particular compensation methodology.

Accordingly, the statement that “percentage management fees are always legal” is too broad. So is the statement that they are “always illegal.”

The actual arrangement matters.

Fair Market Value Is Not a Magic Phrase

Healthcare agreements frequently state that compensation represents “fair market value.”

Including those words in a contract does not establish that the compensation is actually fair market value.

The parties should be able to explain what the MSO provides and why the compensation methodology is commercially reasonable in the context of the relationship.

An MSO providing personnel, office space, equipment, technology, billing support, marketing infrastructure, accounting, and extensive operational support is different from an entity providing only limited administrative services.

Follow the Money

Before finalizing an MSA, the parties should map the entire financial relationship.

Who collects patient revenue? Which entity pays providers? Who pays clinical expenses? Which entity pays administrative expenses? How are MSO expenses reimbursed? When is the management fee calculated? What happens if the practice experiences a cash shortfall?

These details should not be left to informal operational practices after the agreement is signed.

Build the Economics and Legal Structure Together

The management fee should not be drafted in isolation from the broader business arrangement.

Apex Health Law works with healthcare businesses to structure MSO relationships by evaluating the services being provided, the economics the parties are trying to achieve, applicable healthcare regulations, and the actual movement of money between the parties.

The objective is to develop a compensation structure that reflects how the business actually operates rather than forcing the business into a generic MSA template.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Share:

More Posts

Send A Message