INSIGHTS

Articles & Insights.

Thought leadership on the legal, regulatory, and business issues shaping the healthcare industry.

REAL ISSUES.

PRACTICAL INSIGHTS.

AHEAD OF THE CURVE.

Concierge Medicine and Medicare Advantage: When a Membership Fee Can Become a Payer-Contract Problem

Concierge Medicine and Medicare Advantage: When a Membership Fee Can Become a Payer-Contract Problem

Concierge Medicine and Medicare Advantage: When a Membership Fee Can Become a Payer-Contract Problem

Concierge medicine continues to attract physicians seeking greater control over patient volume, scheduling, and professional relationships.

Many practices are developing hybrid models in which patients pay an annual membership fee while the practice continues accepting Medicare or commercial insurance.

The concept can work, but the structure requires careful attention.

The fundamental issue is whether the membership fee charges patients for services that are already covered by their insurance.

Membership Fees Are Not Automatically Prohibited

Medicare recognizes that concierge practices may charge membership fees for non-covered services and amenities.

However, physicians who accept Medicare assignment generally cannot impose additional charges for Medicare-covered services beyond applicable program requirements.

Medicare’s published guidance specifically distinguishes permissible charges for non-covered concierge services from impermissible additional charges for covered medical care. 

That distinction should drive the membership model.

Define What the Patient Receives

A concierge agreement should clearly identify the benefits included in the membership.

For example, the practice may intend to provide enhanced scheduling, certain administrative conveniences, educational resources, or other defined non-covered services.

But simply labeling a service “concierge” does not establish that it is outside insurance coverage.

The actual service must be analyzed.

If a physician charges a membership fee that effectively includes services already payable under Medicare or a commercial payer agreement, the practice may encounter billing and contractual problems.

Medicare Advantage Requires Additional Contract Review

Medicare Advantage introduces another important consideration.

A physician participating in an MA network may be subject to contractual obligations concerning covered services, patient cost-sharing, billing, and other financial arrangements.

Those obligations can be more detailed than the general Medicare rules governing physician charges.

Accordingly, practices should review their MA agreements before determining which services may be included in a separately purchased membership.

A benefit that appears appropriate under a general concierge business concept may nevertheless conflict with a particular payer agreement.

ABNs Are Not a Universal Solution

Some practices assume that obtaining an Advance Beneficiary Notice of Noncoverage resolves any concern about charging Medicare patients.

That is not correct.

ABNs serve specific functions under Medicare’s fee-for-service coverage and financial-liability framework.

They are not a general authorization to charge membership fees for otherwise covered services.

Medicare Advantage plans also have their own coverage-determination and beneficiary-protection processes.

The documentation should therefore be matched to the actual payer arrangement.

The Agreement Should Match Operations

A compliant concierge model requires more than careful contract language.

The practice should ensure that employees understand which services are included in the membership, which services are billed to insurance, and which services may be charged separately.

The financial policy, membership agreement, patient communications, scheduling procedures, and billing workflows should be consistent.

For example, the practice should avoid advertising that a membership includes unlimited medical visits while separately billing a payer for those same covered visits without evaluating whether the overall arrangement is permissible.

Build the Model Around the Payer Contracts

The proper analysis begins with the services and the applicable payer agreements.

Only after those issues are resolved should the practice finalize its membership pricing and patient documents.

Apex Health Law advises physicians and medical practices regarding concierge medicine, direct primary care, membership agreements, Medicare and Medicare Advantage considerations, commercial payer contracts, and healthcare regulatory compliance.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Regulatory reference: Medicare’s Guidance on Concierge Care⁠

Share:

More Posts

Send A Message