INSIGHTS

Articles & Insights.

Thought leadership on the legal, regulatory, and business issues shaping the healthcare industry.

REAL ISSUES.

PRACTICAL INSIGHTS.

AHEAD OF THE CURVE.

When an MSO Has Too Much Control: Clinical Independence and the Captive Practice Problem

A healthcare company forms an MSO. A physician owns the affiliated professional practice. The parties sign a Management Services Agreement stating that the physician retains exclusive authority over clinical matters.

Is that enough?

Not necessarily.

When evaluating an MSO-PC arrangement, one of the most important questions is whether the professional practice maintains the independence required under applicable law—or whether the management company effectively controls the practice despite the formal ownership structure.

Substance Matters

The problem with analyzing an MSO structure exclusively from an organizational chart is that the chart only identifies legal ownership.

It does not necessarily show who controls the business.

A more meaningful review examines the agreements and operational relationships connecting the MSO and professional entity.

For example:

  • Who controls the professional practice’s bank accounts?
  • Who hires and terminates clinicians?
  • Who establishes provider compensation?
  • Who negotiates payer agreements?
  • Who controls medical records?
  • Who determines which medications or supplies are used?
  • Who establishes clinical protocols?
  • Who controls the practice’s budget?
  • Who can terminate the physician owner?
  • Who can transfer ownership of the professional entity?

No single question necessarily determines whether a structure is appropriate. Collectively, however, these provisions can reveal where actual control resides.

Clinical Versus Administrative Decisions

A properly structured MSO can have substantial responsibility for the business side of the organization.

The MSO may manage accounting, payroll support, facilities, non-clinical staffing, technology, marketing, revenue-cycle functions, vendors, purchasing support, and other administrative operations.

The distinction becomes important when management authority crosses into matters requiring professional medical judgment.

For example, an MSO can generally establish an administrative budget. That does not necessarily mean it should determine whether a physician orders a particular diagnostic test or prescribes a particular medication.

Similarly, an MSO may provide recruiting support, but decisions concerning whether a clinician is professionally qualified to treat patients can implicate clinical authority.

The Bank Account Question

Money movement deserves particular attention.

In many structures, patient revenue is earned by the professional practice and deposited into an account belonging to that entity. The practice then pays clinical obligations and amounts owed to the MSO under the MSA.

Operational arrangements sometimes give the MSO substantial authority over those accounts for administrative purposes.

Those arrangements should be carefully documented so that administrative access does not inadvertently become evidence that the MSO owns or controls the professional practice’s revenue in a manner inconsistent with the intended structure.

Succession Arrangements Require Care

MSO structures may also contain mechanisms addressing what happens if the physician owner dies, becomes disabled, loses a license, breaches certain obligations, or otherwise can no longer serve as owner.

Planning for those events can be necessary for business continuity.

But succession arrangements should not simply give a non-physician investor unrestricted power to replace the professional owner whenever it wishes. The applicable state’s ownership and corporate-practice rules should inform how those mechanisms are structured.

Documents Must Match Operations

The biggest mistake may be having carefully drafted agreements that bear little resemblance to how the company actually operates.

A provision declaring that the physician maintains clinical independence is much more meaningful when the organization’s workflows, banking arrangements, provider relationships, and decision-making authority reinforce that principle.

Apex Health Law helps healthcare companies evaluate both sides of MSO structures: what the documents say and what the business actually does.

That distinction becomes increasingly important as healthcare companies grow, accept outside investment, enter new states, or prepare for a future transaction.

This article is provided for general informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice.

Share:

More Posts

Send A Message